Never can or will I forget the injustices suffered by South Asian workers around the world. Cheap and expendable to their employers, few industrial workers and ayahs, butlers, cooks and drivers to the world’s wealthiest are treated with simple human dignity when working hard to send money to their families back home. The stories and statistics linked to physical, psychological and sexual abuse of workers by their “masters” and subsequent suicides, especially in Arabia but also prevalent in Europe and the United States, are shocking and sickening in their scope. So, the following tale of the two-year-long plight of South Indian workers in a Pascagoula, MS shipyard is only that much worse.
SiliconIndia: Indian workers at U.S. shipyard allege human trafficking
More than 100 Indian workers at a Mississippi shipyard staged a walkout claiming they were victims of human trafficking and lived and worked in abysmal conditions.
The workers plan to report themselves to the Department of Justice as trafficking victims and demand federal prosecution of the employer, Signal International, a local television channel WLOX-TV reported. They claim they were lured to come on H2B visas for temporary workers to Pascagoula shipyard run by Signal after Hurricane Katrina caused worker shortage.
… the chain began in 2006 when recruiters in Mumbai and New Orleans together with Signal, a subcontractor, used the post-Katrina labour shortage to create a trafficking racket within the guest worker programme.
The Hindu, South India’s leading newspaper, reports that the workers number in the 400-600s and hail primarily from the southwestern Indian state of Kerala, and that “most of them [are] pipe fitters and welders, [who] had to sell their houses or raise heavy loans to pay the visa amount demanded by the recruiter.” Only a hundred or so of these workers participated in the walkout, while the majority “remained silent for fear of losing their jobs.”
Signal International is not just a shipyard, but a marine fabrication company that constructs oil exploration and production rigs (which makes me feel so much better) and is a major subcontractor to Northrop Grumman Ship Systems. Yes, that Northrop Grumman.
Saket Soni, director of the New Orleans Workers’ Center for Racial Justice, reports that the workers lived “like pigs in a cage” and that he has “never seen these kinds of conditions.” Further details on the living and dining conditions are available in The Hindu article.
Incidentally, Soni and the Workers’ Center were central to the 2006 lawsuit against Decatur Hotels, LLC in which 82 “Latin American workers brought a federal lawsuit [against the hotelier], who lured them through false promises and charged them thousands of dollars in fees to fill jobs held by New Orleanians prior to Hurricane Katrina.” Sounds like a common post-Katrina employment theme – do nothing to bring old workers back and screw over poorly-paid foreign nationals.
It appears the situation was a Catch-22 for the Indian workers, as is normally the case. If they stay and quietly work at their jobs, they are forced to live in the deplorable conditions listed above. If they speak out, they risk deportation and a return to India where they, along with their families, will face severe hardships after having sold most or all assets to raise visa money. Of course, Signal International denies all wrongdoing. To be fair, it is unclear at this time whether Signal’s HR department or the Indo-US hiring company, through which the workers were hired, is at fault.
Everyday, the New Orleans bloggers complain about disaster capitalism in post-Katrina Southern Louisiana and here it is at its worst. Tomorrow, I will contact Saket Soni and find out what is being done to help these men and if the US State Department and any local Indian organizations are involved. The Hindu claims that a local church got the revolting workers together with members of the Center for Racial Justice and that a human rights organization has put these men up in a hotel. Another unanswered question: if former Signal employee, Sabulal Vijayan, was ousted from his job over a year ago for speaking out and if he has already “testified before a Congressional subcommittee investigating post-Katrina labour violations in the region,” why is the story hitting major news outlets only now?
Sadly, it was India that sent us 22 tons of relief supplies in the days of the flood, while our own leadership sat on its hands, and it is repaid by its workers being treated poorly at the hands of a Gulf Coast corporation. As Manish, formerly of Sepia Mutiny, opined on this topic, “The best solution would be for [South Asian nations] to adopt economic reforms and create jobs at home so these [people] don’t have to emigrate in the first place.” Until then, these brave men and women are in constant danger, for the sake of putting food on the family plate. Some in our backyard, no less. Help me find out more about what’s going on at Signal International, pass the story on and let’s brainstorm about how to help get the word out about this and other worker abuses in this area. It’s bad enough that taxpaying Americans suffer indignities at the hands of government and business, especially on the Gulf Coast after late 2005. There is no need to outsource this tragedy.
Update (Sunday, March 9, 2008): From NDTV.com comes news that the Overseas Indian Affairs Minister, Vayalar Ravi, has promised support for Signal’s Indian workers. In addition, the workers have contacted the US Equal Employment Opportunity Commission and “plan to report themselves to the Department of Justice as trafficking victims.”
I’m with you Darlin’!
Sometimes it seems like corporate America goes so way out of the way to be stupid when doing something smart and (coincidentally) right would be so much easier. Geez.
I’m sure you Googled the same things I did. It looks like Signal has denied the charges and has claimed that their program has been investigated by the government and approved. They claim to have invited journalists to visit their facilities.
The few mainstream media reports I saw report on the protest of either 89 or “some 100” workers. Some web sites msay 280 protesters.
Most of the sensational coverage seems to be web sites with an agenda.
I checked the number of plumbing fixtures against the Illinois Plumbing Code (first one I found on line) for dormitories. The number of fixtures cited meet the legal requirement for a dormitory in Illinois.
Like you I’d like to know the truth.
Ignoring the sensational coverage, which I didn’t cite in my above post, I really want to know what’s going on. Asian workers often work abroad in the most horrible conditions and never complain/protest unless the situation has compelled them to speak out. There are also a lot of instances of very similar treatment of workers all over the globe that I wouldn’t put Signal beyond reproach at this time.
Wow you so nail things Maitrisan. When I first returned after the storm I saw a camp over near Iberville Projects? Full of Latinos, with razor wire fence,lights and even a small guard tower. I spoke to a contractor right in front of the place around the end of the day and he said that he had to return his workers there before sunset every day, come get them at sunrise..and had to have the same “count”. Did anyone else see this place? I’m just telling you what I saw. They were on one side of the fence and I on the other. This was around the 1st of Dec ’05.
Anyway you covered so much more ground on this than the article I Ladder’d yesterday. Really, most Americans have no idea what work is like outside thier borders. No idea.
After 9/11 I said to my father that I wondered if we would ever see a “American Refugee”, you know like in trucks running from death that they can’t control…that stuff we see on TV that happens to “them” “over there” that would “never happen here.” And then there I was rushing the bridge in a pick-up truck in a convoy of Refugees to get the fuck away from uncontrolable death in crucified New Orleans, away to Baton Rouge to anywhere 6 days after the levees failed…an American Refugee of my own DamnNation.
Now I hesitate to wonder if Americans will ever feel the sting of working overseas in such a capacity as so much expendable chattle as is commonly dealt foreigner workers. As we lose even more jobs here, will we go to work “over there”? Given our National Karma…I don’t want to go there…I would rather pay “them” better “here”…and don’t mind the citizenship thing either.
Thus spake da’drake…
Like I said, I want to know the truth too.
I am surprised there hasn’t been more mainstream media coverage. Especially if, as Signal claimed, journalists were invited in.
There’s very little independant public information to go on. The Mainstream Media generally simply recite both sides.
One report seemed to point a finger toward the recruiting firm for charging the workers for visas and misrepresenting what their status would be once they arrived here.
According to the article I mention in today’s update to the post, it appears that the culprit is Dewan Consultants of Mumbai (although a firm from nearby Goa is also involved – may be Dewan itself). The article also reports that Signal is now attempting to get more workers through another set of Mumbai-based recruiters, S. Mansur & Company.
Here’s another…
http://news.in.msn.com/national/article.aspx?cp-documentid=1282311
They are really huge. Their site has been “deactivated”:
http://www.dewanconsultants.com/
but you can get them here:
http://www.naukri.com/jg/dewan/cu.htm